Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Non-repair car talk
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

Drove the E55 for the first time today since buying the S550. So that's....9 days? Did a local errand because the rear end was indicating that it was time to drive it again.
20211121_104252.jpg

I was curious how it would feel and not surprisingly I have a few thoughts. I'll cover the highlights.

- Visibility is better. This car has 90s car visibility. It's really impressive. Not that the S550 is bad by any means but it's just exceptional in the E55.

- Steering is worse. It's heavier which some people think translates to sporty but mostly the steering is just worse. It is less direct and has more on-center play (not a ton really but more). It's not unenjoyable of course.

- Brake feel is worse. I expected this. The SBC brakes just don't feel that good. They work OK but the S550 brake pedal feels way better to me.

- Seats. Wow the seats. They are certainly good from a support perspective, for athletic driving styles. Of course, I am comparing an AMG E-class to a non-AMG S-class. But yeah they hug you way more in the E55. Again for sporty driving they are obviously better but I still like the seats in the S550 for what kind of car it is.

- The ride is definitely a lot stiffer. Even in Comfort mode. I do like it but the ride of the S550 is just way better.

- Engine. Good lord yeah this thing is bonkers. The response and torque is just crazy. Again I like the M273 in the S550, for what it is. But there's no comparison with this.

- Overall the E55 feels at least a generation older than the S550. I mean it is an older platform (2003 vs 2007) and was a lower line platform to boot. So I guess this is how it should be. Still, the difference is substantial. If you thought the E55 was fancy, the S550 is in another league. Still, the E55 does feel like a special car so I hope to own it a while.

Overall I was struck how the E55 almost feels as familiar to me now as my Caprice did. It has spiritually replaced my Caprice. Meanwhile I think the S550 is a good replacement for my Fleetwood, which I have been saying I missed since I sold it. Pleased to have a car like this again. They both do things that no B or D body could ever do, even with mods, especially taken as a total package. And yet they both sort of scratch the B/D body itch. Nice. I realize they do not scratch the "this car is basically like working on a 1/2 ton pickup" itch but I am perfectly happy to trade that, cash in on the tools and skills I have (and learn something new), and drive some really cool cars that would have been out of the question otherwise.

As I had hoped, both cars feel special, have a wow factor and are cool in their own different ways. This is all good news but not surprising to me.
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

I think for next year I need to think about some maintenance on this car. I don't really have any symptoms that would cause me to do any of this, other than that cold weather P0505 which I haven't seen since last year. The supercharger reseal might take care of that. Otherwise everything is totally preventative.

- Change supercharger oil. Probably run the latest M1 jet oil stuff. Simple in theory but can be annoying to remove all old oil because it needs a specific amount and you don't want to overfill. It seems that my supercharger may not be original judging by P/N but it's still probably been on there a long time. I have heard of some improvements from fresh oil, including drivability.
Parts: Under $50
Labor: If combined with supercharger removal, pretty low. Still relatively low even if I do in place, but just more tedious.

- Consider removing supercharger and resealing the various gaskets, seals and the bypass valve coupler thing. Of course if I remove then I could drain the supercharger the easy way. I don't remember if I need to remove valve covers for this but I think no. It's just REALLY heavy.
Parts: Probably under $50
Labor: Not sure. Probably 4 hours.

- Fuel pumps/senders. I am having NO issues but the filters are integrated with the pumps. The other issue I'm not having is the tank gasket(s) can leak and cause fuel smell. Many of these cars actually got new gas tanks because the tank itself was somehow compromised. I believe my car is on its original tank. I am afraid to touch it since I have no issues at all but this car is probably overdue for some pumps. It is supposed to be every 60k and I am not sure mine have ever been done. It is recommended to upgrade to the 2 relay harness which is a bit involved. Apparently the single relay design can kind of melt down, and the forum lore says this is exacerbated by clogged filters. This is also an expensive job even as DIY, with parts into the $1000 range. It would give me confidence as far as driving the car hard because if fuel pressure drops, these cars can easily crack #8 piston. It's much less likely with a stock pulley and tune of course. But I still worry.
Parts: Over $1000. https://www.fcpeuro.com/products/merced ... 2714700000
Labor: The pumps themselves, probably only a couple hours being careful. Upgrading the harness and stuff like that will add several more hours.

- Rear main seal job
Parts: Probably under $50
Labor: Pull transmission

- Valve stem seals? (if oil consumption doesn't significantly decrease after the rear main work)
Parts: On the order of $20 for the seals. Have to reseal valve covers so a few bucks for those. Need something to hold valves up while disassembling valve keepers and springs so maybe an air tool in the spark plug hole or some other method.
Labor: Fairly slow process and can be tight in the engine bay. Could be like a 6 hour job....on one bank and maybe half that on the other.

- I feel like the front struts could use a replacement. They mostly feel fine but I don't think the damping is quite what it should be. I did new shocks last year or whenever and the rear feels SIGNIFICANTLY stiffer than the front. I think one strut is original and the other is an Arnott reman. This annoys me anyway. So a brand new pair of OEM Bilsteins would probably help even if I can't point to hard evidence that something is sub-par currently. I should also inspect the front suspension in more detail and more sure I don't see any cracked bushings.
Parts: Ouch, these seem to have gone up a lot. $1500 for a pair of Bilsteins on Rockauto.
Labor: A few hours. Already had them out before for the upper control arms so I know how to do this.

- Bolt-ons. Consider some kind of headers (likely keeping the cats intact which means I am probably limited to a shorty header and they are on the order of $1500 for the cheaper ones and go up from there). Headers are good because these cars have a pretty substantial exhaust manifold restriction. Aside from the performance increase, it also helps with the cooling issues and decreases supercharger boost which also leads to lower intake air temps and thus, higher performance. Another good bolt-on item would be an upgraded intercooler. If I do everything above I could also add an 83 mm pulley and a tune and probably have something that runs 11.5s @ nearly 120. And it would be reliable, not tuned to within an inch of its life. But to get to this point I need to invest in some maintenance and not just go straight for performance mods.

- It might be worth upgrading to the blue top transmission solenoids. These are faster responding and pair well with the TCU tune I have. Not real excited to pull the valve body for a third time but it's not too hard. Realistically I would wait until I at least get some miles on this fluid and work this upgrade into the next fluid service. If so then this is many years off...
EDIT: I may already have these per factory transmission breakpoint and also a photo I found of my own valvebody on the bench. Interesting.

Add it all up and this is multiple thousands. I am OK with the idea of investing into the car to keep it reliable and good-performing but I need to work up to wanting to do all of this. Hence the "next year" thing. An alternate plan is just continue to nurse it along (driving it somewhat occasionally) until something forces me to make a repair (or worse). It's the "or worse" part that bugs me. I think it might come down to ownership horizon. If I plan to keep for the long term, it is probably worthwhile. If I thought I might sell in a year or two I could just sort of keep operating as is since there are no apparent symptoms at all. I am leaning toward keeping it in the longer term.

A more realistic time phased plan would probably be:
Next year replace the supercharger oil, think about an R&R reseal job, and the fuel pumps. Maybe struts also.
The following year I could look into some other of the mods (transmission solenoids, headers, intercooler, pulley, tune, etc.)
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg/497 ... eal-2.html

Need to check my car for this issue next time it's in the air....or actually just back it on ramps and inspect.
Not too bad. Cut an access into the frame like pictured, get a good look around, remove the bolt, reinforce the area, install new bolt. Don't reuse old bolt. It's a torque-to-yield (a.k.a. stretch bolt) designed for a one-time use. Like the crank pulley bolt.

I'd say an hour tops per side for the handyman with the correct tools and materials.
Interesting. It seems like the desired failure mode is actually when the bolt rips out the threads. Then you don't need to extract anything. The solution is just a nut and a bolt with appropriate washers. And cutting a small access hole in the frame (and repairing after). Way easier than dropping the subframe.

I do think MANY of the failures are actually due to dropping the subframe for other work and simply reusing the bolts and even improperly torqueing them.
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

Good news: I won't have to spend any money maintaining the car. Because it's totaled.
20220824_163503_HDR.jpg
20220824_163509_HDR.jpg
20220824_163527_HDR.jpg
20220824_163533_HDR.jpg
20220824_163955.jpg
20220824_164001_HDR.jpg
20220824_164010_HDR.jpg
20220824_164014_HDR.jpg
20220824_164031_HDR.jpg
20220824_164448_HDR.jpg
20220824_172333_HDR.jpg
20220824_172338_HDR.jpg
20220824_172358.jpg
20220824_172527_HDR.jpg
20220824_172534_HDR.jpg
20220824_172540_HDR.jpg
20220824_173550_HDR.jpg
20220824_174915_HDR.jpg
20220824_174920_HDR.jpg
20220824_174925_HDR.jpg
20220824_174937_HDR.jpg
20220824_174944_HDR.jpg
20220824_174950_HDR.jpg
20220824_174955_HDR.jpg
20220824_175711.jpg
20220824_175716_HDR.jpg
20220824_175721_HDR.jpg
20220824_180723.jpg
20220824_181400.jpg
20220902_151824_HDR.jpg
20220902_151829_HDR.jpg
20220902_151835_HDR.jpg
20220902_151916_HDR.jpg
20220902_151925_HDR.jpg
20220902_151931.jpg
20220902_151944_HDR.jpg
20220902_155512.jpg
20220902_155517_HDR.jpg
20220902_155521_HDR.jpg
20220902_155531_HDR.jpg
20220902_155537_HDR.jpg
20220902_155738_HDR.jpg
20220902_155741_HDR.jpg
20220902_155745.jpg
20220902_155750_HDR.jpg
20220902_155754_HDR.jpg
20220902_155756_HDR.jpg
20220902_155802_HDR.jpg
20220902_155806_HDR.jpg
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

After over 5 months, it's done.

https://youtu.be/qvO4y-QH-kw
kevm14
Posts: 15238
Joined: Wed Oct 23, 2013 10:28 pm

Re: Mercedes E55 AMG hunt (W211)

Post by kevm14 »

Post Reply