Page 3 of 3

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2025 11:11 am
by kevm14
From the other thread

Says I shouldn't have a cooler and I don't. I don't know why this wouldn't be reflected in EPC.
Screenshot_20250419_121021_OneDrive.jpg

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2025 7:55 pm
by kevm14
Acting up more consistently now. Seems like maybe after 21 minutes it smooths out finally but that also could be because that's about when I get off the highway.

So I gave up and ordered another one. I guess if this next one acts up I will have to reconsider my options.

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Tue Apr 29, 2025 12:34 pm
by kevm14
Acted up yesterday morning but the afternoon was warmer and it was fine. It's almost like there is a temp range where it is sticky or something like that.

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Sat May 03, 2025 5:34 pm
by kevm14
Pressurized to around 15 psi and checked for leaks. Found none.
20250503_143430.jpg
Replaced the thermostat again. 152k.

Shots of the job and the thermostat I put in around late Dec/early Jan. I see nothing wrong with it. This was extra easy because the gasket came off cleanly and I tried harder to avoid moving the air pump out of the way and succeeded. I vacuum filled and also ran the engine with the heater maxed.
20250503_151344.jpg
20250503_151348.jpg
20250503_151353.jpg
20250503_151411.jpg
20250503_151416.jpg
20250503_151418.jpg
20250503_151421.jpg
20250503_151622.jpg
20250503_151642.jpg
And the new thermostat
20250503_151703.jpg
20250503_152457.jpg
20250503_153302.jpg
My small pile of thermostats.
20250503_164736.jpg

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Sat May 03, 2025 5:41 pm
by kevm14
Road test and decided to monitor thermostat duty cycle, coolant temp and target coolant temp. I've never really done this before so I have no data. The results are extremely interesting.

Basically what it does is drop the duty cycle to zero which targets 211F or so. Perhaps this is the natural control temp of the thermostat (mechanically). Then at first it seemed to randomly target like 176F and crank the duty cycle to 99%. Once it was able to pull temps all the way down (and sometimes as low as 173F) it seemed to raise the target again and drop duty cycle to 0%. However, if I was heavy on the throttle (and I mean only for 3 seconds) it would once again raise duty cycle to 99% and target 176F. Only when it achieves something in this range will it raise the target again! If I am easy on the throttle, it seemed to just stay at the target of 211 and actual coolant temps were like 206-212 or so. This is so odd. I really wish I monitored this with the previous thermostat. However, I do have evidence of it failing its own test. I guess I should run the test again on a brand new thermostat and see what it does.

Hypothesis: whacky temp control but the old thermostat was also misbehaving. More to come I guess.
1746308748903.png
1746308786863.png
1746308806176.png
1746308838986.png
1746308888093.png
1746308914317.png
1746308936096.png
1746308985228.png
1746309019385.png
1746309027577.png
1746309039432.png
1746309203007.png
1746309271584.png
1746309310712.png
1746309327465.png
1746309335649.png
1746309393270.png
1746309416869.png
1746309464866.png
1746309598943.png
1746309620522.png
1746309703998.png
1746309977118.png
1746309987002.png
1746310388366.png
1746310414242.png

Re: 07 S550: thermostat

Posted: Sat May 03, 2025 8:14 pm
by kevm14
Found some info in WIS. Some of this seems to be like M276 era info and probably a little hotter temps than my M273 runs. Also, I checked the resistance of both my original thermostat and the one I had in there earlier this year. They were both around 15.8 ohms which is within spec...